This is a statement that needs careful unpacking, because there is no general medical warning that eating one banana a day is harmful for healthy people over 50.
However, the statement may be referring to a specific risk for a subset of people over 50: those with chronic kidney disease (CKD), especially moderate to advanced stages.
Here’s why:
-
Potassium content – A medium banana has about 400–450 mg of potassium.
-
Kidney function declines with age – Many people over 50 have undiagnosed reduced kidney function.
-
Risk of hyperkalemia – If kidneys cannot excrete potassium efficiently, eating a banana daily could contribute to dangerously high potassium levels, leading to heart arrhythmias or cardiac arrest.
For a healthy person over 50 with normal kidney function, one banana a day is not just safe—it’s beneficial (fiber, vitamin B6, potassium for blood pressure control).
But if the statement is presented as a general warning, it would be misleading. The accurate version would be:
“If you’re over 50 and have chronic kidney disease (especially stage 3b or worse), eating one banana a day could cause dangerous potassium buildup.”